Wednesday, December 24, 2025

2025 Top Five

Welcome to my top five acquisitions of 2025! It was a good year for the collection, with some longtime grails achieved, and some things I didn't expect! In no particular order:

Top of the list of things I didn't expect - gray Winnifred straight from Breyer - so last minute she snuck onto this list and knocked someone else off
Longtime grail - loose mane Shannondell, bought on time pays from my dear friend Kelly M. 
Appaloosa Valerio, completing my Valerio set
The 2004 JCPenney Parade of Breeds G1 Arabian Stallion, courtesy of Heather B.
One of my luckiest eBay lot finds - a no stamp dapple gray G1 ASB, who has been cleaning up in the show ring
The full top five lineup - I made out pretty good this year!

Wednesday, December 17, 2025

Live Show Secrets: What Makes LSQ? (And Why It's Not What You Think)

 I've noticed in this hobby, we have a tendency to expect perfection. I see it from all walks of collector - casuals to hardcore showers. Tiny flaws are nitpicked to death, returns are demanded when a model doesn't meet the standard set in one's head. 

And I'm here to say - it's mostly bull. 

There are of course, flaws that are genuinely returnable - broken pieces, noticeable scratches, big things essentially. Tiny things, less so. Poor dappling and shading are not returnable reasons, nor are flaws that are nearly indiscernible to the human eye or a camera lens. A good general rule of thumb is if you have to circle the flaw in the photo, it's probably not returnable. 

But in most cases, you cannot and should not expect perfection from mass-produced factory models. It's an impossible goal! This doesn't just apply to Breyers - it's across the board, applicable to Stones, Schleich, CollectAs, WIAs. Even with customs and artist resins, you can't expect 100% perfection. Spend any amount of time talking with hobby artists or existing in the customizing and finishwork groups and you'll see they have to reach a point in prep work where it's good enough - perfection is not a reachable goal. 

So then, what makes a model live show quality if every model is expected to have some level of flaws? Let me debunk it for you! 

If you've been following the blog for a while, you may know my credentials from my judging clinics, but for those new here I'll list them again. My name is Macie and I've been collecting since 2008. My collection focuses on OF Breyer. I've been around horses in some capacity since roughly 2001. I was in 4-H for seven years, showed in IHSA in college, and was a working student at an eventing barn. I've photo shown model horses on and off since 2015, and have been live showing since 2022. I have had multiple overall champions in breed and collectability in both OF Breyer and OF Mini divisions. I started judging in a small capacity in 2022, and since fall 2024 I have judged at several shows, including Are You Kitten Me, the Happy Kamper Classic, the Big Orange Bash, and the River City Classic. I have also volunteered for NAN in 2022 and 2024, and did additional volunteer work for NAMHSA for BreyerFest 2025.

Find the information under the jump - keep in mind, as an OF collector, this will be written slanted in that direction. Customs and artist resins may be held to a different standard. 

Friday, December 12, 2025

It's Friday, I'm a Judge! Breed: American Gaited

Happy Friday! It's time for another judging clinic. We're back in the land of mini breed today. Like with our last breed judging clinic, we're stepping out of a class for a single breed and instead evaluating several breed assignments against each other. 

As per usual, my credentials can be found on my About Me page. 

This week, we'll be examining an American Gaited mini breed class. This could encompass several breeds, such as the American Saddlebred, the Tennessee Walking Horse, the Rocky Mountain Horse, and the Spotted Saddle Horse, among others. It's entirely possible depending on a show's class list that some of these breeds could be split into their own classes (particularly ASBs and TWHs) but for the purpose of this judging clinic we'll be lumping them together. 

The Entries: 
Saddlebred mare
Saddlebred: 
  • Well-shaped head with large expressive eyes and gracefully shaped ears set close together, long arched neck with a fine clean throatlatch, deep and sloping shoulders
  • Strong and level back, level croup, tail carried proudly 
  •  Front legs set well forward under the shoulder, hind legs vertical from point of buttock to the back edge of the cannon bone
  • All colors acceptable: chestnut, bay, brown and black are most common, with gray, roan, palomino and pinto occurring
Information courtesy the American Saddlebred Horse & Breeders Association https://www.saddlebred.com/aboutthebreed

Horse A: G1 Saddlebred

Tennessee Walking Horse mare
Tennessee Walking Horse:
  • Definitive head with small well-placed ears, long sloping shoulder, long sloping hip
  • Fairly short back, short strong coupling, bottom line longer than top line 
Information courtesy the Tennessee Walking Horse Breeders' & Exhibitors' Association https://twhbea.com/the-breed/conformation/ 

Horse B: G3 Tennessee Walking Horse

Saddlebred mare
Saddlebred: 
  • Well-shaped head with large expressive eyes and gracefully shaped ears set close together, long arched neck with a fine clean throatlatch, deep and sloping shoulders
  • Strong and level back, level croup, tail carried proudly 
  •  Front legs set well forward under the shoulder, hind legs vertical from point of buttock to the back edge of the cannon bone
  • All colors acceptable: chestnut, bay, brown and black are most common, with gray, roan, palomino and pinto occurring
Information courtesy the American Saddlebred Horse & Breeders Association https://www.saddlebred.com/aboutthebreed

Horse C: G2 American Saddlebred

Take a minute, look over the documentation, and decide how you would place this class. When you're ready, my placings can be found under the jump. ↓

Wednesday, December 10, 2025

Conga Time! G1 Thoroughbred Mare

 It's my birthday! As a celebration, we're taking a closer look at one of my favorite Breyer molds - the G1 Thoroughbred Mare. 

The Thoroughbred Mare mold captured my heart early - I was first exposed to it through a knockoff horse set, probably purchased at a craft store for one of my birthday parties, long before I knew about Breyers. 
Like, all G1 molds, I have a tendency to compulsively buy them when I see them - this has lead to this conga having a ton of duplicates! 
Despite the compulsive buying, I realized when I made this post that I'm missing more than I thought I was! I guess it's a good thing - it gives me something less outrageously expensive to look for next year! 
I've also been working on my collection catalog off and on for the last few years - I have a huge collection, so it takes a lot of time between recording the models and taking and labeling photos. This conga has stalled the G1 tab of the spreadsheet because with all the duplicates I wasn't sure what I actually had! I took advantage of having the whole conga out to take individual photos. Progress will commence once again! 

A selection of my favorites! 
I don't believe this girl is anything special - I just think her leg shading is both weird and cool. I got her from eBay earlier this year. I'm fairly confident she's #5026, so she's grouped with them for the purposes of this post, but she could equally be an early #5141. 
I was SO EXCITED when she was used for the 2017 Stablemates Club. Coco is a lovely bay sabino. I'd love to see Breyer bring her out more often - they've used Native Dancer twice, give this lady time to shine! 
I just love this mold in modern colors - this is the Hidalgo Mustang Set from Blockbuster. Like her sister A Clear Day, she was one of the earliest models I wanted to track down when I seriously re-entered the hobby in college. 
This girl may be familiar to those who follow my Show Reports - this is my NIB copy of #5028. She was a gift from one of my dearest hobby friends Kelly M., who named her for me - Eras Tour! 
You know her, you love her, she's the focus of her own Collection Spotlight - it's the 2004 JCP Holiday Catalog, known in my collection as A Clear Day.
#5028 Variations
#5030 Variations - the mare on the left is a no stamp
#5026 Variations
                   
                        1990s Regular Runs - #5140 at the top, three variations of #5141 at the bottom
#5183 Variations
90s Special Runs - 1998 Sears Holiday Catalog on the left, 1995 JCP Holiday Catalog on the right
The Modern Era Girls - 2004 JCP Parade of Breeds, Blockbuster Hidalgo Set, Stablemates Club Coco
My two NIB girls - #5183 on the left, #5028 on the right
A shrinky! She's a very proportional one, but set her next to any of her sisters and she's significantly tinier. 

Saturday, December 6, 2025

Book Review: Dear Readers and Riders by Lettie Teague

I have a little bonus post for you today! Outside of model horses, one of my great loves is reading. To that end, I plan on having the occasional horse or hobby related book review. These won't be on any sort of schedule, just as the whim takes me. Without further ado, let's get into the first ever Macie's Model Horse Musings book review. 

Dear Readers and Riders by Lettie Teague

I believed I've mentioned it before, but I work in processing in a library. This means I'm the first one to handle the books that come in, as I unpack the boxes and check the contents against the purchase orders. This one came across my desk last year, and I immediately jotted down the title to read in the future. Well, in the time since I majorly fractured my arm and then went straight into show season, which throws a wrench in most of my free time. As show season began to wind down, I was looking through my notes for books to read and came across this one. It was purchased for the main location I work out of, so I nipped over to the stacks and brought it home for reading. 

Dear Readers and Riders examines the life and writing process of Marguerite Henry, as well as her impact on readers. Marguerite Henry is best known as the author of Misty of Chincoteague and its various sequels, in addition to numerous other horse books for children, such as King of the Wind and Brighty of the Grand Canyon

The book starts with a look into Henry's personal life before her writing career, starting as a child and moving into her adult years. From that point, the chapters are broken down into her most popular books and her writing process for each. There's less focus on her personal life, though it does come up in passing. What I found most interesting was not only the amount of research she put in (often traveling to the locations where her books were set, and interviewing real people), but her collaborations with her illustrators, particularly Wesley Dennis. I was also pleased to see how much Henry valued libraries, and how much she relied on local librarians for her research! 

The last portion of the book covers Henry's impact on popular culture, including the film adaptations of her work and the Breyer models made after them. Both Stephanie Macejko of Breyer and Peter Stone were interviewed, and there were several photos included of the various Breyer models, their advertisements, and packaging. BreyerFest itself even got a shoutout! 

This author has definitely not been offered a jello shot in the hallway of the CHIN

What I valued most about the book was its consistency in highlighting the impact Henry had on young horse enthusiasts. Teague includes scans of letters between Henry and various fans, and highlights the personal relationships Henry developed with the children who read her books. It was heartwarming to read about the pen pals she had, and how she allowed the neighborhood kids to ride Misty and throw her birthday parties.  

One thing I wish was that the chapters went a little more in-depth. As I mentioned, once Teague gets into the writing process of each book, mentions of Henry's life decline. The chapters are also quite short, in favor of covering as many of Henry's popular books as possible. 

Overall, I found the book enjoyable. I learned more about Marguerite Henry and her writing process, and it was fun to read about the process of how her models became Breyer models. I'd recommend this book to those looking to find out more about Henry, but maybe not those who are familiar with her already. I know personally I'd like learn a little bit more about her life, and I'll definitely be keeping an eye out for other books about her. 

Wednesday, December 3, 2025

Monthly Round Up! November Additions

Happy December! It's time to look at what I added to the collection in November. Even with a swap meet, it's been a lighter month for me - I had an emergency vet visit for one of my cats, and I'm making payments on a few cool things. I foresee this continuing into the holiday season, with final Club purchases and renewals to come.

Starting the month off strong, we have glossy Cossaco! My friend ordered a CCA appreciation this fall, and I told her if it was glossy Atlanta or Cossaco, I'd take it off her hands. So naturally, it was Cossaco. I picked him up from her at  Off to the Races. 

As you can see, I added another Stone to the collection this month. They dropped a Taylor Swift themed collection to commemorate the anniversary of the Indianapolis Eras Tour show. As Erin said, the alternate name for the collection was "Macie Says She Doesn't Collect These, The Musical." And I took that personally 😂 I tried for two in the collection - the Tortured Poets mule and the palomino Drafter. The Drafter got yoinked from my cart, but the Tortured Poets mule came home to me! 

Breyer threw us for a loop when this year's Winter decorator model came with a mini-me! Killington and Little Killington were released on the Traditional and Stablemate scales of the Fighting Stallion mold. While I adore the mini version of the mold, I don't actively collect the big guy. Luckily I found a friend willing to split the set. Little Killington stayed with me, and Killington was packed up and shipped out to his new home. Win win! 

Breyer luck was not in my favor with the Short and Sweet blind bags. Unfortunately, I did not end up with a Coal, so I'll have to track one down on time pays once the market cools a little. I received doubles of the blue and gold Zebras, and have already found trades for the two colors I'm missing. They'll likely show up in a future blog post, as I know I won't be receiving the red one until May (the friend I'm swapping with is Canadian and with the state of tariffs we agreed to wait until we could swap in person). I also finally got one of the mini whinny chase models I was missing!

I was supposed to be good at the Pre-Holiday Plastic Pony Palooza swap meet this year - and I mostly was! I did got slightly overbudget by agreeing to time pays for the Julien and Sophia set, but they've been on my ISO list for a while. The pinto Scotty is another I've been after for a while, and he was way under the budget I had for one. The G1 TB Foal is a no-stamp, which is my current G1 obsession. And yes, those are two more Stone Chips you see! The bay Friesian was very reasonable and I hadn't managed to add one on that mold. The Mule came from my friend Fran, who is a very good saleswoman - she sold him to me for half off and mentioned he came from her mother's collection. How could I say no to that! The party seal was a free with purchase with the Friesian. I just think he's neat. 

Sunday, November 30, 2025

Stablemate Sunday: Deluxe Collector Club Stablemates 2020-2024

 The release of Darius in September got me thinking about the previous Deluxe Collector Club Stablemates. Last year was their fifth year of the Deluxe Collector Club, so I thought a little retrospective on the first five years of the Club would be nice! 

The Deluxe Collector Club began in 2020. There is no true difference between the base Collector Club and the Deluxe Collector Club besides the bonus Stablemate (and as of 2023, the bonus pin). The additional cost of the Deluxe Collector Club essentially pays for the bonus items in advance. The bonus Stablemate and pin ship anytime from the fall to the end of the year. 

Prince was the first Deluxe Collector's Club stablemate. He is a glossy palomino on the miniature Fighting Stallion mold. As 2020 was the 70th Anniversary of Breyer, Prince is a reflection of that. He is a miniature version of #33 King, the Fighting Stallion, one of the classic vintage Breyers. He came in a silk bag commemorating the 70th Anniversary.  

Chalice was the second Deluxe Collector Club Stablemate. Released in 2021, he sports the same paint job as the 2019 auction model on the traditional version of the mold. At the time, the 2019 auction model held the record for the highest amount an auction model had been sold for. Chalice is a lovely glossy buckskin sabino with ermine spots. His color is so wonderfully done for a Stablemate! 

Ellington is perhaps my favorite of the Deluxe Collector Club Stablemates. Unlike Prince and Chalice, Ellington is not a callback to a previous model. He is a glossy bay tobiano on the Standing Friesian (aka Django) mold. He has been a phenomenal show model for me, with several NAN cards under his belt.  

The 2023 Deluxe Club Stablemate was Fandango. He's a lovely dappled black sabino on the Twist mold. Fandango came in a silk bag with his name on it, and additionally came with an exclusive pin featuring Bolero, one of the Collector Club web specials for that year. Like Ellington, Fandango is not a miniature of any previous release, but both are on molds that debuted in the Stablemate Club, which I find interesting! 
Horatio was the 2024 Deluxe Club Stablemate. He showed a return to form for the club, being on a shrunken version of an existing traditional mold, much like Prince and Chalice. Horatio debuted the miniature Othello mold. He is a gray sabino in the pattern of Heath, who was a Collector Club web special that year. Heath is also featured on the 2024 Collector Club pin. I really enjoyed the concept of the deluxe Stablemate sporting the same pattern as the open to all web special. 

Friday, November 28, 2025

It's Friday, I'm a Judge! Traditional Collectability #2

This week, we're back to collectability judging! Today we're looking at a Traditional scale Premier Club class. 

As always, my personal judging credentials can be found on my About Me page. 

Without further ado, let's look at the entries this week! 

The Entries: 

Horse A: Bobby Jo - 2015 Premier Collection - #90174 - Unknown amount made

Horse B: Hamilton - 2019 Premier Collection - #90193 - Unknown amount made - Signed by sculptor Jennifer Scott

Horse C: Ashquar - 2013 Premier Collection - #90167 - 753 made

When you're ready, my placings are under the jump ↓

Wednesday, November 26, 2025

Collection Spotlight: 2004 Parade of Breeds G1 Thoroughbred Mare

 On this collection spotlight, we're looking at one of my absolute favorite models in my collection - the G1 Thoroughbred Mare from the 2004 JCPenney Parade of Breeds set. 

This set in particular is a holy grail set to me - every piece is fantastically well done, and many of them are sought after by collectors for this reason. I plan on covering this in a future Stablemate Sunday, so I won't go in too much detail, but I only finished tracking the whole set last year. 

This model is a matte rose gray on the G1 Thoroughbred Mare mold. She has resist dappling on her neck, shoulders, and haunches. She has a white mane and tail, and four socks. She additionally features eye whites. 
This model in particular has always been my favorite in the set. When I first started getting back into the hobby in college, she was one of the first models I wanted to track down. I'm partial to both grays and sport horses, and she's such a lovely shade of rose gray. I think I tracked her pretty quickly, but my records from that time are fuzzy. It's safe to assume she's been in my collection about a decade at this point. 
She is also notable for being one of the last releases on the Thoroughbred Mare mold before the license to use the Hagen-Renaker molds expired. She wouldn't be used again in the Breyer lineup until the 2017 Stablemate Club release Coco. 
If you show with me, her show name should be familiar to you - this is A Clear Day (named for the Barbra musical On a Clear Day You Can See Forever). She's taken an overall in breed in three shows by my count at this point. It's always nice when one of your favorite models also does well for you! 
The one place she didn't do well was NAN 2024 - through no fault of her own! The Thoroughbred class was combined traditionals and minis, and it's a tough world out there for minis in a mixed class. One of the judges did place her, so I was still proud regardless. She's going back to NAN in 2026, so we'll see if she can get some redemption! 


2025 Top Five

Welcome to my top five acquisitions of 2025! It was a good year for the collection, with some longtime grails achieved, and some things I di...